The Options You Want With The Service You Deserve.

Wagner Agency has been a trusted name in the Pittsburgh area since 1941. As an independent agency with 30+ carriers, we find the right coverage for your home, your car, and your business without the runaround.

Home icon

Home Insurance

Protect your Pittsburgh home from the unexpected.

Black car front icon on a white background

Car Insurance

Coverage that follows you across Pennsylvania.

Black outline of a house above a car, suggesting a home garage or parking icon

Bundle Home & Car

Multi-policy discounts for your home and auto.

Umbrella over document and dollar icon, suggesting insurance or financial protection

Commercial Insurance

Protect your business from risks that matter most.

Allstate
Berkley
CNA
Geico
Nationwide Insurance
The Generak
Travelers

Personalized Insurance Designed for You

Whether protecting your family, your business, or your most valuable assets, Wagner Agency offers tailored policies built around your needs. With 80 years of Pittsburgh experience and 30+ top-rated carriers, we make sure you have the right coverage at every stage of life.

Personal Insurance

Family Insurance

Protect your home, your car, and the people who matter most with personalized coverage from one of the Pittsburgh area's most trusted independent agencies.

Commercial Insurance

Business Insurance

Keep your Pittsburgh area business running strong with policies designed to cover every angle, from general liability to workers compensation to niche industry coverage.

Coverage Options

Explore Specific Coverage Options

Personal Insurance Includes:

Simple black outline of a car front view on a white background

Auto Insurance

We shop 30+ carriers to find auto coverage that fits your driving habits, your vehicle, and your budget across Pennsylvania.

Airplane icon over a suitcase, suggesting travel baggage transport

Travel Insurance

Give your family the financial security they deserve with travel plans tailored to every trip, every destination, and every budget.

Outline icon of a key over a user avatar

Renters Insurance

Find quality renters coverage that protects your belongings and your liability without the confusion of navigating the market on your own.

Business Insurance Includes:

Briefcase with shield and checkmark security icon

General Liability Insurance

Protect your Pittsburgh area business from customer injury claims, property damage, and legal expenses with the right liability coverage.

Hand holding a coin with a dollar sign icon above it

Workers’ Compensation

Protect your employees and keep your Pennsylvania business compliant with the right workers compensation coverage

Black outline of two buildings, one taller, on a white background

Commercial Property Insurance

Safeguard your building, and business assets from fire, theft, and unexpected losses with coverage tailored to your operation.

Why choose us?

Why Pittsburgh Area Families and Businesses Trust Us

For over 80 years, we have earned our neighbors' trust the old-fashioned way, by showing up, picking up the phone, and finding coverage that actually fits. With 30+ carriers, deep roots in the Pittsburgh area, and a team that genuinely cares, we deliver the kind of experience big-box agencies simply cannot match.

Independent Agency

Independent by Design

We are not tied to one insurance company. With 30+ carriers in our network, we compare rates and coverage side by side so you always get the best deal, not just the only option.

Awarded Agency

A Pittsburgh Legacy Since 1941

Founded in Pittsburgh's historic financial district in 1941, Wagner Agency has built its reputation one honest conversation and one satisfied client at a time.

Friendly Agency

Coverage That Grows With You

Life changes and your insurance should too. From your first home to your growing business, we adjust your coverage at every stage so you are never overpaying or underprotected.

Start Your Quote the Way That Works for You

Need Help Right Now?

Most visitors start here when they need help after hours.

Get a Quote

Get A Quote

Chat With Us

Chat With Us

Call
Email

Leave us a note

OR

Talk to a Licensed Insurance Specialist

Leave your details and a licensed agent will review your request.

Contact Us

By providing your phone number and submitting this form, you consent to receive informative SMS messages from Wagner Agency at the number provided. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Message & data rates may apply. Message frequency varies. Unsubscribe at any time by replying STOP or Reply HELP for help. View Terms of Service and Privacy Policy for more information.

Insurance Tips and Resources

Three professionals discussing documents in a bright office interior.

Independent vs Captive Agent: Why It Matters More Than You Think for Pennsylvania Families

By Wagner Agency • June 15, 2026
Choosing between independent and captive agents impacts your coverage and cost. Learn why independent agents offer more options for Pennsylvania families.
Person working at a desk with a laptop and notebook, looking thoughtful in a bright plant-filled office

What Every Small Business Owner in Pittsburgh Should Know Before Buying Commercial Insurance

By Wagner Agency • June 15, 2026
Pittsburgh business owners face unique insurance needs. Learn what coverage protects your company from liability, property damage, and business interruption.
Hands shaking over a house model on blueprints, with a laptop in the background.

Why Pittsburgh Homeowners Need More Than a Standard Policy in 2026

By Wagner Agency • June 15, 2026
Standard home policies often fall short in Pittsburgh. Learn what additional coverages protect your home from flooding, sewer backup, and other local risks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Your Insurance Questions Answered

  • What types of insurance does Wagner Agency offer?

    Wagner Agency offers a full range of personal and commercial coverage including auto, home, renters, motorcycle, RV, boat, general liability, workers compensation, commercial property, commercial auto, and much more. We also specialize in niche industries including nursing homes, home healthcare, restaurants, breweries, technology firms, non-profits, and private security companies.

  • What is the difference between an independent insurance agent and a captive agent?

    Independent agents like Wagner Agency work with multiple insurance carriers, giving you access to dozens of options and competitive rates. Captive agents represent only one company, which limits your choices. We shop the market on your behalf across 30+ carriers to find the best coverage at the best price for your specific situation.

  • How quickly can I get an insurance quote?

    You can get a quote from Wagner Agency by calling us directly at (412) 681-2700 or submitting a request online. Most quotes are provided quickly and we will compare options from multiple carriers to make sure you are getting the best value for your coverage needs.

  • Does Wagner Agency offer business insurance?

    Yes, and commercial coverage is one of our biggest strengths. We offer policies for businesses of all sizes and industries including general liability, workers compensation, commercial auto, commercial property, and specialized coverage for restaurants, nursing homes, breweries, technology companies, and more.

  • Can I bundle my home and auto insurance to save money?

    Absolutely. Bundling your home and auto insurance is one of the best ways to lower your premiums. Wagner Agency works with 30+ carriers that offer multi-policy discounts and we will find the combination that gives you the most coverage for your budget.

HQ Address

Our Location

Pennsylvania

Address

5020 Centre Avenue, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15213, United States

Business Hours

Mon - Fri : 08:30 am - 04:30 pm

Contact

No obligation · No sales pressure

Ready to Compare Rates and Save?

Prefer to talk to a real person? Give us a call and we will answer your questions and provide a quote over the phone. No hassle and no hard sell — just honest advice from Pittsburgh's most trusted independent agency.