Wagner Agency proudly represents

Cincinnati Insurance

The Cincinnati Insurance Company, operating since 1950, stands among the nation’s top 25 property casualty insurer groups based on net written premiums. The group markets business, home and auto insurance products through a select group of independent insurance agencies in 39 states. The Cincinnati Life Insurance Company subsidiary actively markets life and disability income insurance and annuities in all states except New York.


• Pay by Phone 800-364-3400

Pay Online

• Report Claim 877-242-2544

• Report Glass Claim 877-588-4527


• Pay by Phone 888-242-0888

Pay Online

• Report Claim 877-242-2544

Report Claim Online

Did you know Cincinnati Insurance Companies has an app that allows you to view policy documents, view your mobile ID card, make payments, get accident tips and access roadside assistance?

Download the Cincinnati Insurance App:

Cincinnati Insurance Companies